Skip to content

Country

tistaminis

How to Test a New Miniature Paint Range Without Buying Every Colour

Test a new miniature paint range by buying the smallest selection that answers a real painting question. One useful colour can test handling; three carefully chosen colours can explore several jobs. Compare them with paints you already own on matching primed surfaces, record the dried results, and expand only when the new paints solve a problem.

You do not need a white, yellow, black, metallic, and skin tone simply because a checklist recommends them. Choose colours for your next project. A paint that you never use is a poor test purchase, however impressive its first coat looks.

This guide takes you through a compact comparison session, a hypothetical worked example, and a clear keep-or-buy decision. It focuses on brush-applied hobby paints; follow the specific product instructions for specialized formulations.

Start With a Question, Not a Shopping List

Write down what you want the new paint to improve. “Is this range good?” is too broad. Try one of these instead:

  • Can this pale colour give me a smoother bone basecoat?
  • Does this red make my usual armour recipe easier?
  • Can I paint cleaner edge highlights with this colour?
  • Does this coordinated colour family simplify choosing shadows and highlights?
  • Will this metallic give me the finish I want on weapons?

Pick your success criterion before testing. Fewer coats, cleaner control, a more suitable finish, or less mixing time are different benefits. You do not need one paint to win every category.

Choose a Small, Useful Test Selection

Your goal Useful first purchase What it can tell you
Check basic handling One frequently used colour How that paint behaves in your normal technique
Explore several everyday jobs Two or three project colours, such as bone, red, and brown Whether those individual colours suit your work
Try a coordinated highlighting system A dark, middle, and light selection from one family Whether the progression improves colour choice and transitions
Compare metallic finishes One metallic you actually need Coverage, particle appearance, and reflection on your model
Try transparent or one-coat painting A product intended for that workflow Control over raised areas, recesses, and colour buildup

A small sample cannot establish the quality of an entire range. Whites, bright colours, neutrals, and metallics may behave differently. Keep your conclusions attached to the exact colours and jobs tested.

Set Up a Fair Comparison

You need the new paints, your closest existing alternatives, suitable primer, a palette, a familiar brush, test pieces, labels, and somewhere to record results. Spare miniatures or textured pieces reveal handling around details; a flat piece makes streaks and opacity easier to see.

  1. Use matching surfaces. Prepare and prime both samples in the same way. Allow the primer to dry as directed.
  2. Label the samples. Record paint names and primer colour so similar swatches do not become a guessing game.
  3. Choose comparable paints. Match intended use and approximate colour as closely as practical. Note differences rather than pretending two unequal hues are identical.
  4. Control the environment. Compare in the same session where possible, using consistent lighting and similar application conditions.
  5. Use your familiar technique. A test should reflect how you will actually paint, not a method chosen solely to make one product look impressive.

Start with the primer you normally use. If performance over another primer matters, run a second matched pair. Comparing one paint over white with another over black does not isolate the paint's contribution.

Run Four Useful Tests

1. Working Consistency and Brush Control

Mix each paint according to its instructions. Note its starting consistency, then adjust it appropriately for the task using water or a suitable medium where recommended.

Do not insist on identical dilution: paints can begin at different consistencies. Record how much adjustment each needs and compare them at a useful working consistency.

Try a small flat area, a raised edge, and a detailed recess. Look for predictable release from the brush, unwanted pooling, streaks, and whether you can place paint where intended.

2. Dried Coverage and Surface Quality

Apply a controlled coat, let it dry, and inspect how much primer remains visible. Add another coat if needed and record the number required for your intended result.

A thick coat is not a fair shortcut if it obscures detail. Look at smoothness and detail retention alongside opacity. If the product is intentionally transparent, judge whether it produces the desired effect rather than marking transparency as a failure.

3. Your Actual Painting Technique

Test the job you chose at the start: edge highlighting, layered highlights, glazing, drybrushing, or another intended application. Use a comparable process with your existing paint.

Sharp edges are not a defect when you want a crisp highlight; they may be undesirable when you are trying to create a soft transition. Judge against your goal rather than a universal definition of “smooth.”

If you use a medium, record it. Keep an unmodified sample where useful so you can distinguish the paint's behaviour from the paint-and-medium combination.

4. Working Time and Dried Finish

Observe how much usable time you have for the technique and when a thin test layer can accept the next application without being disturbed. Use a sacrificial area for checking rather than repeatedly touching the main sample.

Dry-to-touch and fully cured are not necessarily the same. Follow product guidance before handling heavily, varnishing, or drawing conclusions about durability.

Compare dry samples under the same light and angle. Note colour, sheen, visible texture, and metallic reflection where relevant. A photograph can help you remember the result, but keep physical samples because camera processing can change the appearance.

A Worked Example: Three Paints for a Fantasy Unit

This is a hypothetical test plan, not a report of measured results. Imagine your next unit needs bone, red cloth, and brown leather. You already own usable versions, but want to see whether a new range improves the process.

Colour Test against your existing paint Buying decision
Bone Basecoat matching primed details; compare dry coverage and texture Add it if it produces the finish you prefer with acceptable effort
Red Paint a cloth section and add your usual highlight Keep your current red if the new one offers no useful improvement
Brown Basecoat a strap and apply a controlled edge highlight Retest at a different suitable consistency if handling is promising but initially unfamiliar

You might decide to add only the bone, keep your familiar red, and reserve judgement on the brown. That is a successful test: you learned what to buy without turning curiosity into an unnecessary full-range purchase.

Do not add a metallic merely to complete this experiment. If metallic weapons are a priority, give a suitable metallic its own comparison against one you already use.

Keep a Short Test Record

Use one entry per paint. A few specific observations are more useful than an unexplained score out of ten.

  • Setup: paint, comparison colour, primer, surface, brush, and technique.
  • Adjustment: mixing, water, or medium needed for control.
  • Coverage: dry coats required for the intended result.
  • Handling: pooling, edge precision, brush marks, and detail retention.
  • Finish: dried colour, sheen, and texture under consistent light.
  • Workflow: whether it saved time, reduced mixing, or made a difficult step easier.
  • Decision: add this colour, keep the current paint, or run one focused follow-up test.

For example: “Two controlled coats over my usual primer; clean edge control after a small adjustment; finish suits the project; buy this colour again.” Avoid turning that observation into “the whole brand is better.”

Make the Buying Decision

Add the Individual Colour

Buy or keep it when it clearly solves your chosen problem. You can prefer different manufacturers for different colours without rebuilding your whole collection.

Keep Your Existing Paint

If the result is similar and your current paint is dependable, there may be no reason to switch. Familiarity and repeatable recipes have value.

Retest One Specific Issue

If the result is ambiguous, change one relevant variable: working consistency, primer, or application method. Do not change everything simultaneously and then assume you know what fixed it.

Consider a Set Only After Checking Its Contents

Compare the exact set with the colours you will realistically use. A lower average price per bottle does not help if much of the box duplicates paints you own or sits unused.

If you are considering a set, the Army Painter paint sets collection at Tistaminis gives you options to compare by their listed contents and current prices. This is a shopping route, not a claim that every set or colour has been tested here.

Compare Cost Without Losing Sight of Usefulness

For a basic size comparison, divide the current price in CAD by the stated volume in millilitres. Compare like-for-like prices and include any medium you need in your overall budget.

Price per millilitre does not measure performance. Also consider the number of coats, rework, ease of application, and how often you will use the colour. A more expensive paint may be worthwhile for a difficult task; an inexpensive unused bottle is still wasted money.

If you are curious about a coordinated progression, a concrete catalogue example is Tone Pro Gnarlwood 1, Gnarlwood 3, and Gnarlwood 5. Check individual listings for current details and availability, and choose them only if that family serves a project you want to paint.

What Not to Conclude From a Small Test

  • One excellent colour does not prove every colour in the range behaves the same way.
  • A transparent paint is not poor quality simply because it fails an opaque-basecoat test.
  • One awkward first attempt does not establish that a paint cannot work with your technique.
  • Layering products in sequence and mixing them directly are different compatibility questions. Test unfamiliar combinations and follow manufacturer guidance.
  • Strong coverage does not automatically mean better glazing, blending, or metallic appearance.

Testing Miniature Paints FAQs

How many colours do I need?

Start with the smallest selection that answers your question. One colour can test a specific replacement; two or three can explore several useful jobs. A broader sample provides more information but still does not represent every formulation.

Do I have to test white and yellow?

No. They can be informative when those colours matter to your projects, but buying colours you will not use defeats the purpose. Choose a useful pale or bright colour rather than following a mandatory list.

Should every paint receive the same amount of water?

No. Record adjustments and compare at a suitable working consistency for the same task. Identical added water can produce very different handling when starting consistencies differ.

Should I test over both black and white primer?

Begin with your normal primer. Add another primer comparison if you need to understand that use case, keeping the new and existing paints on matching surfaces within each pair.

How do I compare washes or one-coat paints?

Use a test miniature with raised detail and recesses, the recommended preparation, and a comparable product intended for the same job. Judge the effect and control, not just how effectively it hides the primer.

Can I use paints from different brands on the same model?

A new paint does not require replacing your whole workflow. Test unfamiliar combinations on spare pieces, allow layers to dry as directed, and check specific product guidance. Do not assume all paints and mediums can be mixed directly.

Your Next Step: Test One Real Painting Problem

Choose the job, select the smallest useful sample, compare it with what you own, and write down the decision. The goal is not to identify one winning brand. It is to build a collection of paints you enjoy using and can rely on.

Finish the test on a spare piece before switching a whole unit to a new recipe. Expand colour by colour when the results justify it, and leave the rest of the range on the shelf until you need it.

Previous article Are Premium Miniature Paints Worth the Price?
Next article Warhammer Tone Pro Paints: First Reactions From Miniature Painters